Cheapest we found in United States
Buffalo, NY
$9.16
at Gino's NY Pizzeria
cheapest of 17 areas
typical $17.95
up to $17.99 in Commack
Every baked stuffed shells price in Buffalo
- DineForLess
- Dishes
- United States
- Baked Stuffed Shells
Baked Stuffed Shells across United States
17 areas · 67 kitchens · typical $17.95
We hold a best price for baked stuffed shells in 17 areas across United States, read from 67 kitchens serving it. The cheapest is $9.16 at Gino's NY Pizzeria in Buffalo, NY, and the dearest best price is $17.99 in Commack, NY, so the best price in one town is $8.83 more than in another, which is 96% more for the same dish.
Typical prices run from $11.50 to $21.85 depending on the town, with $17.95 in the middle, so a price much under that is worth crossing town for and a price over it is what most kitchens charge. The areas sit in 2 states, led by New York with 10 areas. The menus behind these prices were read between 1 Sep 2026 and 17 Oct 2026.
Every area, cheapest first
| Area | Best price | Typical there | Kitchens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buffalo, NY | $9.16
$2.34 under |
$11.50 | 6 |
| Denville, NJ | $10.95
$5.05 under |
$16.00 | 3 |
| Ridgewood, NY | $11.00
$5.00 under |
$16.00 | 4 |
| Somerset, NJ | $11.00
$6.99 under |
$17.99 | 3 |
| Flushing, NY | $11.50
$1.97 under |
$13.47 | 8 |
| Great Neck, NY | $11.50
$7.45 under |
$18.95 | 3 |
| Blairstown, NJ | $11.75
$1.73 under |
$13.48 | 3 |
| West Islip, NY | $12.99
$4.64 under |
$17.63 | 4 |
| Medford, NY | $13.00
$4.95 under |
$17.95 | 4 |
| Huntington, NY | $14.75
$2.79 under |
$17.54 | 5 |
| Washington, NJ | $14.95
$4.00 under |
$18.95 | 4 |
| Hamilton, NJ | $15.50
$3.49 under |
$18.99 | 3 |
| Massapequa, NY | $15.80
$2.19 under |
$17.99 | 4 |
| Hoboken, NJ | $16.95
$2.05 under |
$19.00 | 3 |
| Mahwah, NJ | $16.95
$1.00 under |
$17.95 | 3 |
| Lindenhurst, NY | $17.75
$4.10 under |
$21.85 | 3 |
| Commack, NY | $17.99
$1.01 under |
$19.00 | 4 |
Where baked stuffed shells costs the most
Commack, NY
Domenico’s Italian Eatery · 4 kitchens compared
$17.99typical $19.00
Lindenhurst, NY
Mr G's Pizzeria & Restaurant · 3 kitchens compared
$17.75typical $21.85
Mahwah, NJ
Esposito's Pizza · 3 kitchens compared
$16.95typical $17.95
Hoboken, NJ
Rosario's at Willow · 3 kitchens compared
$16.95typical $19.00
Massapequa, NY
Via Roma Pizza · 4 kitchens compared
$15.80typical $17.99
Hamilton, NJ
The Best Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant · 3 kitchens compared
$15.50typical $18.99
Baked Stuffed Shells by state
| State | Areas | Lowest best price | Typical in the middle |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York
45 kitchens |
10 | $9.16
Buffalo |
$17.95 |
| New Jersey
22 kitchens |
7 | $10.95
Denville |
$17.99 |
Each best price is the lowest we read for baked stuffed shells in that area, and the typical price beside it is the middle of every price we hold for the dish there. Items are grouped by dish, so the name on a menu varies a little between restaurants. Prices are compared within one country only, because a Canadian dollar is not an American one. See how we read prices.