Nonna's Pizzeria, town by town

3 locations · 3 areas · 60 menu prices compared

Cheapest plate under this name

French Fries in Mahopac

$4.20 typical $5.75 in Mahopac

29 under the local typical 20 over it

3 restaurants in United States trade under the name Nonna's Pizzeria, in 3 of the areas we cover and 2 states. We hold 60 menu prices from them. Of those, 29 are under the typical price of the town the restaurant is in and 20 are over it, so across every town this name is $38.07 under the local typical in total.

The dish it prices in the most towns is Parmigiana, on 3 menus in different areas. The cheapest is $13.95 in Wappingers Falls and the dearest is $20.95 in Mahopac, a difference of $7.00 for the same item on the same menu, or 50% more in one town than the other.

These are grouped by the name on the door, not by who owns the restaurant: the prices we read do not say that, so some of these will be branches of one chain and some will be unrelated kitchens that chose the same name. The menus were read between 5 Sep 2026 and 8 Oct 2026.

The same dish in different towns

Dish	Towns	Cheapest	Dearest	Gap
Parmigiana	3	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$20.95 Mahopac	$7.00
Wings	3	$10.95 Wappingers Falls	$14.70 Mahopac	$3.75
Pizza	3	$11.50 Gilbertsville	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$2.45
Francese	2	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$25.20 Mahopac	$11.25
Marsala	2	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$25.20 Mahopac	$11.25
Piccata	2	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$25.20 Mahopac	$11.25
Eggplant Rollatini	2	$10.50 Mahopac	$20.95 Wappingers Falls	$10.45
Baked Ziti	2	$13.95 Wappingers Falls	$19.95 Mahopac	$6.00
French Fries	2	$4.20 Mahopac	$8.95 Wappingers Falls	$4.75
Chicken Scarpariello	2	$21.95 Wappingers Falls	$26.50 Mahopac	$4.55
Pasta And Meatballs	2	$15.95 Wappingers Falls	$19.95 Mahopac	$4.00
Cacciatore	2	$22.95 Wappingers Falls	$26.50 Mahopac	$3.55
Chicken Sorrentino	2	$22.95 Wappingers Falls	$26.50 Mahopac	$3.55
Lasagna	2	$15.95 Wappingers Falls	$18.90 Mahopac	$2.95
Stromboli	2	$9.45 Mahopac	$11.50 Gilbertsville	$2.05
Parmigiana Sandwich	2	$8.95 Wappingers Falls	$10.95 Gilbertsville	$2.00
Salad	2	$8.95 Wappingers Falls	$10.30 Gilbertsville	$1.35
Calamari	2	$13.65 Mahopac	$14.95 Wappingers Falls	$1.30
Veal Sorrentino	2	$25.20 Mahopac	$25.95 Wappingers Falls	$0.75

Every town we have prices from

Area	Locations	Cheapest here	Against the town
Mahopac, NY 28 dishes priced	1	$4.20 French Fries Nonna's Pizzeria	9 under, 16 over $23.23 over in total
Wappingers Falls, NY 25 dishes priced	1	$4.75 Garlic Knots Nonna's Pizzeria	15 under, 4 over $54.48 under in total
Gilbertsville, PA 7 dishes priced	1	$9.95 Italian Hoagie Nonna's Pizzeria	5 under, 0 over $6.82 under in total

Every price here is one we read from that location's own menu listing on the date shown on its area page, for dishes enough other kitchens in the same town also serve. The typical price it is measured against is the middle of every price we hold for that dish in that town, so the same item can be under the typical in one area and over it in another. See how we read prices, or tell us one is wrong.