395 Shanley St
Dearer than Buffalo on the whole
$24.34
over the typical price of the same 15 plates
4 under the typical price
1 level with it
10 over it
Menu and online ordering
- DineForLess
- New York
- Buffalo
- Papa J's Pizza
Papa J's Pizza
15 dishes priced in Buffalo · menu read 9 Oct 2026
Every dish we hold a price for
| Dish | Here | Typical in Buffalo | Where that sits |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Pizza
Cheese Pizza · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$8.24
$6.71 under
|
$14.95 |
3rd cheapest of 40
$6.95 best$14.95
$6.95 at Carbone's Pizza & Subs
|
|
Parmigiana Sandwich
Chicken Parmesan Sub · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$8.99
$1.00 under
|
$9.99 |
7th cheapest of 23
$6.99 best$9.99
$6.99 at Ricota's Pizza
|
|
Chicken Taco
Chicken Taco · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$6.99
$0.96 under
|
$7.95 |
4th cheapest of 9
$6.49 best$7.95
$6.49 at Desi's Pizzeria
|
|
Onion Rings
Onion Rings · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$5.49
$0.46 under
|
$5.95 |
8th cheapest of 20
$4.39 best$5.95
$4.39 at Ricota's Pizza
|
|
Beef Taco
Beef Taco · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$6.99 | $6.99 |
4th cheapest of 6
$5.95 best$6.99
$5.95 at Desi's Pizzeria
|
|
Wings
Chicken Wings · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$15.99
$0.99 over
|
$15.00 |
23rd cheapest of 34
$7.99 best$15.99
$7.99 at Pizza & Chicken Delights
|
|
Pizza Logs
Pizza Logs · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$9.99
$1.00 over
|
$8.99 |
13th cheapest of 15
$6.99 best$9.99
$6.99 at Mayback's Pizza & Subs
|
|
Salad
Dinner Salad · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$9.99
$1.00 over
|
$8.99 |
33rd cheapest of 52
$4.19 best$9.99
$4.19 at Emergency Pizza
|
|
Shrimp
Shrimp Dinner · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$15.99
$1.00 over
|
$14.99 |
6th cheapest of 6
$11.00 best$15.99
$11.00 at Mike & Pop's Bistro & Tavern
|
|
Steak Hoagie
Steak Hoagie · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$14.99
$3.00 over
|
$11.99 |
11th cheapest of 12
$7.49 best$14.99
$7.49 at Hot Spot
|
|
Fish Sandwich
Fish Sandwich · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$13.99
$4.00 over
|
$9.99 |
9th cheapest of 9
$4.99 best$13.99
$4.99 at Mayback's Pizza & Subs
|
|
Garlic Bread With Cheese
Garlic Bread with Cheese · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$9.99
$4.00 over
|
$5.99 |
7th cheapest of 7
$4.95 best$9.99
$4.95 at Carbone's Pizza & Subs
|
|
Burger
Hamburger · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$13.99
$4.99 over
|
$9.00 |
10th cheapest of 10
$5.49 best$13.99
$5.49 at Ricota's Pizza
|
|
Loaded Fries
Loaded Fries · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$14.99
$6.49 over
|
$8.50 |
6th cheapest of 6
$5.99 best$14.99
$5.99 at Ricota's Pizza
|
|
Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger · read 9 Oct 2026
|
$14.99
$7.00 over
|
$7.99 |
14th cheapest of 14
$5.49 best$14.99
$5.49 at Ricota's Pizza
|
How Papa J's Pizza prices compare
We hold 15 prices from Papa J's Pizza at 395 Shanley St, each for a dish other kitchens in Buffalo also serve. Of those, 4 are under the typical Buffalo price, 1 sits level with it and 10 are over it. Added together the 15 plates come to $171.60 here against $147.26 at the typical price for each, so this kitchen is $24.34 dearer across the same menu, which is 17% over.
Its best value is Pizza at $8.24, $6.71 under the $14.95 typical across the 40 kitchens serving it in Buffalo. At the other end, Cheeseburger is $14.99 here, $7.00 over the $7.99 typical, and the cheapest in town is $5.49 at Ricota's Pizza.
This menu was read on 9 Oct 2026. A price is what the menu listed on that day, not a daily special, so Papa J's Pizza may have changed it since. This price came from an online ordering page rather than the restaurant's own site.
Prices here are the ones we read from this restaurant's menu for dishes that enough other kitchens in Buffalo also list, so they can be compared. It is not the whole menu. The typical price beside each one is the middle of every price we hold for that dish in Buffalo. See how we read prices, or tell us one is wrong.