5 restaurants in Brewster list stuffed shells on their menus. The cheapest is Pizza Place & Trattoria II at $16.85. The typical price across town is $20.48, and the dearest we found is $21.95 at Sinapi's Pizzeria, so the two ends of the list are $5.10 apart, which is 30% more for the same dish. Of the 5 kitchens listed, 2 charge more than a dollar under the typical price, 2 sit within a dollar of it and 1 charges more than a dollar over.
We track stuffed shells in 250 other areas and compare them all on stuffed shells across United States. The typical price there runs $16.45 at the median, so Brewster is dearer than most of them, with a lower typical price than 6 of the 250. The lowest best price anywhere we cover is $5.50 at Mr P Pizza & Pasta in North Wales, PA, and the highest best price is $20.10 in West Springfield, MA. The nearest area with it is Bethel, about 10 mi away, where the best price is $12.95.
Where is the cheapest stuffed shells in Brewster? Pizza Place & Trattoria II, at $16.85 on 35 Main St. The same dish reaches $21.95 elsewhere in town, so where you order it changes the bill by $5.10.
What should stuffed shells cost here? About $20.48 is the typical price across the 5 kitchens in Brewster that list it. Of the ones listed above, 2 are more than a dollar below that and 1 is more than a dollar above, so the typical price is a middle rather than a floor.
Is it cheaper nearby? The nearest area we track it in is Bethel, about 10 mi away, where the best price is $12.95. That is $3.90 less than the best here, though whether that is worth the journey is your call.
Why do the prices differ so much? We compare what each menu calls the same dish, and menus are not identical: portion, cut, sides and the kind of room you are sitting in all ride on the price, and none of that shows up in a number. Part portions and half sizes are kept out of this comparison, and a chain charging the same at several addresses is counted once, so the spread above is between genuinely different kitchens rather than the same one repeated.
| Area | Best price | Typical | Places |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brewster, NY this page |
$16.85 | $20.48 | 5 |
| Bethel, CT
Grassy Plain Pizzeria & Restaurant · about 10 mi away |
$12.95 | $15.60 | 3 |
| Yorktown Heights, NY
Grandma's Pizza (Formerly Nino's Pizza Cafe) · about 14 mi away |
$13.95 | $16.25 | 4 |
| Lake Mohegan, NY
Westbrook Pizzeria · about 15 mi away |
$10.50 | $14.10 | 3 |
| Cold Spring, NY
Route 9 Deli & Pizzeria · about 17 mi away |
$11.95 | $15.00 | 3 |
| Fishkill, NY
Florina's Woodburning Pizza · about 17 mi away |
$14.51 | $18.00 | 5 |
| Wappingers Falls, NY
Pizza Time Restaurant · about 20 mi away |
$14.99 | $16.95 | 5 |
| Norwalk, CT
John's Best Pizza · about 23 mi away |
$12.00 | $14.00 | 3 |
| New Windsor, NY
Midway's Villa Roma · about 23 mi away |
$9.95 | $13.95 | 3 |
| Newburgh, NY
Stella's Pizzeria Restaurant · about 23 mi away |
$13.00 | $19.00 | 3 |
| Fairfield, CT
D'Angelo's Pizza · about 25 mi away |
$15.75 | $17.25 | 3 |
| Poughkeepsie, NY
Sicilian Delight · about 25 mi away |
$10.29 | $16.50 | 7 |
| Bridgeport, CT
La Margarita Pizzeria · about 26 mi away |
$10.00 | $19.75 | 4 |
Items are grouped by dish, so names vary a little between restaurants. Each price is what that menu listed on the date shown beside it, not a daily special, so a restaurant may have changed it since. The typical price is the middle of every price we hold for this dish in Brewster.